Lennon or McCartney (2014)

"Lennon or McCartney" (2014), a captivating documentary produced by Scared Goose Productions in Canada, delves into the intriguing question that has puzzled music enthusiasts for decades: which of the two legendary Beatles, John Lennon or Paul McCartney, is the superior songwriter? Through a series of insightful interviews with a diverse array of musicians, the film explores the unique contributions of each artist to the Beatles' iconic catalog and their individual solo careers. The documentary's strength lies in its ability to present a balanced perspective, allowing viewers to appreciate the distinct genius of both Lennon and McCartney while celebrating their collaborative magic. The film's format is both simple and effective, featuring short, candid interviews with over 500 musicians from various genres and generations. From rock legends like Ringo Starr and Yoko Ono to contemporary artists such as Questlove and Reggie Watts, the documentary showcases the widespread influence of Lennon and McCartney's work. Each interviewee is asked the titular question, "Lennon or McCartney?" and their responses provide a fascinating glimpse into the personal and professional impact of the Beatles' music. The diversity of opinions and the genuine passion expressed by the interviewees create a compelling narrative that keeps viewers engaged throughout the film. One of the most striking aspects of "Lennon or McCartney" is its ability to transcend the typical music documentary format. Rather than relying on archival footage or a chronological retelling of the Beatles' story, the film focuses on the emotional and creative resonance of Lennon and McCartney's songs. The interviewees' stories and anecdotes highlight the ways in which the duo's music has inspired and shaped their own artistic journeys, offering a fresh perspective on the enduring legacy of the Beatles. This approach not only appeals to die-hard fans but also attracts a broader audience interested in the power of music to connect and inspire across generations. "Lennon or McCartney" is a testament to the enduring impact of the Beatles and the timeless nature of their music. Produced by Scared Goose Productions, the documentary serves as a celebration of the creative partnership between John Lennon and Paul McCartney, while also acknowledging their individual brilliance. Through its unique format and diverse range of interviewees, the film offers a thought-provoking exploration of the question at its core, ultimately leaving viewers with a deeper appreciation for the genius of both Lennon and McCartney.